(Photo: Jakob Brooks/WCSN)
TEMPE – As temperatures continued to drop and every clock across Tempe read well past midnight under the bright lights of Mountain America Stadium, thousands of fans decked out in maroon and gold collectively held their breath.
In its first overtime home game since Oct. 2015, Arizona State football had a golden opportunity to ensure that its final performance on home turf during the 2026 season would be remembered as a thrilling victory. The Sun Devils held Oklahoma State to a 35-yard field goal on the opening possession of extra time, putting them 25 yards away from kicking off the morning of Nov. 22 with a bang.
On ASU’s first play on offense, first-year quarterback Jake Fette motioned left while first-year running back Cardae Mack received the snap out of shotgun. The halfback immediately pitched the ball into the hands of the signal caller, and as he drifted to the right side of the field, he lofted a pass in the direction of second-year wide receiver Raiden Vines-Bright.
However, both the quarterback and wideout could only watch as third-year safety Quinton Hammonds swooped in and snagged the ball with one hand for the game-sealing interception, cementing ASU’s (6-5, 4-4 Big 12) 30-27 loss to Oklahoma State (7-4, 5-3 Big 12) as a result of a meltdown that was already long in the making.
“There’s tens of plays that kind of completely changed the name of the game,” head coach Kenny Dillingham said. “There’s so many plays that you can look at that could change the outcome of that game, not just the final play.”
On Saturday night, the Sun Devils donned throwback jerseys akin to the 1986 team that took home a Rose Bowl victory. They initially honored the uniforms by playing up to their standard in the first half.
Fette followed up an initial three-and-out on ASU’s first possession with a 1-yard touchdown pass to fourth-year wide receiver Reed Harris to tie the game at seven points apiece. Early in the second quarter, he rushed into the end zone himself from the goal line to become the first quarterback in program history to throw for, receive and run for a touchdown in their freshman season.
The wave of offensive momentum reached its peak when a deep pass from Fette bounced off the hands of second-year defensive back LaDainian Fields and into Harris’ bread basket for a signature 60-yard touchdown immediately after the two-minute timeout.
By the end of the first half, Fette completed 11-of-16 pass attempts for 179 yards and recorded three touchdowns; two of which went to Harris, who ultimately finished with eleven receptions for 172 yards.
“We had a real good game plan, I think the coaches put together a real good game plan,” Harris said. “We just came out and executed it.”
Meanwhile, ASU’s defense faced the momentous task of limiting the nation’s third-best scoring offense led by second-year quarterback Drew Mestemaker. The highly touted NFL draft prospect entered Mountain America Stadium as the Division I FBS leader in passing yards and touchdowns, but as the contest reached the halfway point, his unit produced a season-low of 129 total yards of offense.
The defensive line not only held the halfback room of second-year Caleb Hawkins and fourth-year William Mason to just 35 yards on 11 carries, but produced two sacks via first-year Julian Hugo and fourth-year Jalen Thompson against a Cowboys team that had only allowed 11 sacks through 10 games.
ASU built up a 24-7 lead in the meantime and received the second-half kickoff, yet an immediate three-and-out became the first domino to fall in the ensuing chain reaction. An offense that amassed 264 total yards in two quarters punted the ball three consecutive times, averaging 3.2 yards per carry on 37 total rushing attempts and the Cowboys adjusting their coverage of Harris eventually took its toll.
“I think I’ve got to do a better job (of) making sure we get the ball to Reed,” Dillingham said. “We didn’t get the ball vertically down the field to him, and part of that was we weren’t running the ball effectively, so they could play shell coverage to him to make it very hard for us to do that in the second half.”
Oklahoma State saw the window to reestablish its offensive rhythm and ran with it, rattling off 17 unanswered points on three scoring drives. Most of the damage came from Hawkins’ two rushing touchdowns, but the Sun Devils didn’t do themselves any favors by failing to keep pressure on Mestemaker and allowing him to single-handedly outgain them in the second half through 183 passing yards.
“I did a bad job forcing him to feel uncomfortable in the second half because he felt way too comfortable regardless of circumstances,” Dillingham said. “We’ve got to find a way to make him uncomfortable and we didn’t do that.”
Such circumstances began with fourth-year defensive back Adrian “Boogie” Wilson getting ejected due to a targeting penalty during the Cowboys’ first drive of the second half, hampering a secondary that had already lost third-year defensive back Rodney Bimage Jr. and sixth-year defensive back Lyrik Rawls for the season.
First-year defensive back Zeth Thues reaggravating a hamstring injury and third-year defensive back Kyan McDonald also exiting the game only further weakened ASU’s depth at a critical juncture.
“That limits what you can do,” Dillingham said. “You’re on your fifth guy at a position. Then, you’re playing a guy who is really good at recognizing coverage, and it’s a tough place to be in. It is what it is. It’s unfortunate, but we still had plays out there that could have been made.”
The Sun Devils responded by putting together an 11-play, 54-yard drive that ended in a 38-yard field goal and put the defense in a position to secure the win with three minutes and 17 seconds remaining. Eight plays later, the Cowboys put a 43-yard field goal through the uprights to send a game at Mountain America Stadium into overtime for the first time since a 61-55 loss to Oregon in triple overtime on Oct. 29, 2015.
One last chance to escape the impending collapse presented itself when second-year defensive back Jessiah McGrew nearly hauled in an interception on a third-and-two, but the ball bounced out of his hands and allowed Oklahoma State to walk away with a field goal. Minutes later, the Cowboys’ sideline erupted in celebration while Fette sat on the turf in disbelief.
“Everybody’s been in that moment, I’ve been in that moment,” Harris said. “You just learn from it. It’s tough for him just to have to experience something like that considering it’s his first turnover of the season, but I’m still proud of him.”
While ASU’s late-season momentum shift has been halted in its tracks along with the streak of not losing a game when possessing a lead entering the third quarter since the start of the 2024 season, the true salt in the wound comes in the bitter end to the program’s Senior Day festivities.
“This senior class came here when we were three wins and under NCAA sanctions,” Dillingham said. “They came here at the lowest point that it could be. They chose us, and they have completely changed the culture here. They’ve changed everything about the expectations here, and I think they can be remembered as that foundational group that really changed and reset Arizona State in the right direction.
“I’m just disappointed we couldn’t get that one for some of those guys that that’s going to be their last game in that stadium. That’s a very painful one to be the last game.”
The 2026 regular season concludes with a trip to Tucson for the 100th edition of the Territorial Cup against No. 19 Arizona on Saturday evening. A victory in the state’s penultimate rivalry game can provide a satisfying ending to a rollercoaster campaign, yet to do so, the Sun Devils will need to take a long, hard look at how the win slipped from their grasp against the Cowboys.
“I think the biggest thing that this team has discovered is that we have the willpower to fight and strain,” third-year linebacker Martell Hughes said. “We’ve been going at it for eight weeks, and just persevering through all the hard times, but also falling back to the process and just counting on one another.”