WCSN Off Campus

Joey Chestnut devours Key lime pie, headlines UCF-Arizona State pregame

(Photo: Mia Bencich/WCSN)

ORLANDO, Fla. — Facing a decorated opponent often brings a different level of pressure. Ask anyone who competed against Tom Brady or Michael Phelps in their primes; they’ll offer plenty of reasons why.

Whether competitive eating qualifies as a sport remains open for debate. One argument against the designation is that virtually anyone can enter. But Joey “Jaws” Chestnut isn’t just anybody, and his presence alone can make a contest feel comparable to facing Brady or Phelps.

Chestnut is best known for his 18 victories at the Nathan’s Famous International Hot Dog Eating Contest. He also holds the world record, consuming 83 hot dogs and buns in 10 minutes. Yet that’s just one of his 55 records.

On Saturday, the challenge was something sweeter than a hot dog. Two hours before Central Florida kicked off against Arizona State, the program invited Chestnut to take on four teams of two in a race to devour 20 slices of key lime pie from Publix, a Southeastern supermarket chain.

Few foods have escaped Chestnut’s reach, and Florida’s state pie is no exception. He set the record in 2006, downing 10.8 pounds in eight minutes. More than 20 years later, he was back for another helping.

Each competitor stared at four whole pies and a cup of water. In the end, Chestnut stood alone, finishing all 20 slices in under four minutes. He maintained a steady pace, taking one sip of water after every slice.

“Key lime pie is definitely a different kind of contest than hot dogs,” Chestnut said. “Hot dogs with the meat, the fat and the grease, it’s a little bit harder. This one is just all the same flavor, it’s easy. I could definitely eat a lot more.”

Before Chestnut took the stage, Teams One through Four were introduced. A fun fact accompanied each contestant before they walked onto the stage. Team Three member Jack was introduced with a bold claim: before the contest, he said Chestnut was “no match” for him.

His teammate, iHeartRadio host and Heisman voter Brandon Kravitz, visibly questioned the announcement that he brushes his teeth with mustard. Kravitz appeared less confident, posting on X earlier: “0% chance this doesn’t end in an L and a stomach ache.”

Team Three finished second with eight slices. Despite the lopsided result, Chestnut wasn’t entirely calm.

“There’s always some sort of pressure,” Chestnut said. “The audience is expecting me to come out here and dominate, so I need to turn it on.”

Chestnut wasn’t the only high-profile name; UCF men’s basketball third-year center John Bol was one of Team Four’s participants. The night before, Chestnut attended the Knights’ 84-70 win over Georgia Southern, where there was also a key lime pie eating contest. Those winners made up Team One.

Before the event, Bol got a chance to meet Chestnut and wagered for his Mustard Belt, a championship-style belt Chestnut brought to Orlando. As Bol shoveled pie into his mouth, the announcer declared he was struggling.

“John Bol, he’s a sweet dude,” Chestnut said. “He wanted to put his watch on the line for the belt. I was like, ‘Dude, you’re going to lose your watch,’ which he did.”

Chestnut signed autographs and took photos with fans for five minutes before the contest. In the hour leading up to it, Florida-based hip-hop group 69 Boyz performed several songs to energize the crowd, including its hit “Tootsee Roll.” 

People stuck around afterward for an extended meet-and-greet with Chestnut. Many also stayed for 95 South, whose “Whoot, There It Is” sparked a yearslong dispute with Tag Team over the similarly named “Whoomp! (There It Is).”

A cold front prompted many to wear warmer clothing. Temperatures hovered around 63 degrees, but the wind made it feel closer to 58. Chestnut, dressed in a polo and shorts, didn’t appear bothered by the conditions.

“I walked around some of the tailgates and everyone is just happy,” Chestnut said. “The UCF culture is amazing, it’s a sweet place. You guys have some of the best weather in the country.”

After Chestnut wolfed down his fourth slice, chants of “Joey” grew louder than Technotronic’s “Pump Up the Jam” playing in the background. For a moment, it sounded less like a pie-eating contest and more like the reception normally reserved for accomplished athletes.

Every great athlete has a recovery process. Chestnut is no different.

“High fiber diet, no sugar, no starches. I should be pretty close to normal (weight) by Monday,” Chestnut said. “I have a reason to be chubby … I gain weight, I lose weight, but it’s alright. It’s part of the job.”

Use Facebook to Comment on this Post

Tyler Weiss

Recent Posts

Well-rounded effort pushes the Sun Devils past the Lady Lions to remain undefeated

TEMPE – In 1984, Bruce Springsteen brought his Born in the U.S.A. tour to the…

13 hours ago

Sun Devils dominate Penn State despite delay, remain undefeated

TEMPE – After an unprecedented delay due to a nationwide ground stop, the sports world…

13 hours ago

Sun Devils ‘got to continue to build on’ UCF win with Senior Night clash against Oklahoma State

(Photo: Ryan Petcove/WCSN) TEMPE — On Friday night, the Federal Aviation Administration’s nationwide ground stoppage…

19 hours ago

After two seasons in Tempe, Lucy Fazackerley’s legacy is ‘bravery at the back’

(Photo: Jordan Keats/WCSN) Some players make their mark with goals and highlight-reel moments. For fourth-year…

21 hours ago

No. 8 Sun Devils continue Territorial Cup dominance in JJ Van Neil era

TUCSON – They dominated. Again.  Through a mosaic of red fans and players, the small…

2 days ago

No. 8 Arizona State sweeps Arizona behind Vajagic’s career day

TUCSON – A ruthless punch darted to the floor. A targeted push dispatched to deep…

2 days ago